Tips for the best and nicest restaurants in Reykjavik, Iceland
Reykjavik is bursting with restaurants, with even a few star gems. We recommend the tastiest places:
(First things first: PLAY Airlines is a so-called low-cost carriers with a base in Iceland. PLAY Airlines flies to Europe and North America for very competitive prices under the motto 'Pay less, PLAY more'. Streamlined no-nonsense service, they say themselves, and safety first. And then the best PLAY deal: you can make a ten-day stopover in Iceland for free, and then fly on to New York, for example. Double holiday!)
Make a reservation well in advance, but then you'll be rewarded. Ding-dong, ring the bell at 18pm sharp at the lovely retro cocktail bar Amma Don for an aperitif (also recommended if you want to stick to just drinking) and then hop, through a door hidden behind a bookcase to the restaurant area, where you'll be served the most delicious dishes with seventeen people at a kitchen table. Chef Thrainn Freyr Vigfusson is inspired by traditional Icelandic dishes, but gives them a very modern and creative aftertaste. Worthy of a star, Michelin thought. Intimate sixties atmosphere, especially the cocktail bar is a feast for the eyes. Price is fixed (count on a small fortune), drinks included. Not cheap, but a treat.
Of course – or maybe – you want to try some of the country's specialties in Iceland. Of course, there is a lot of fish, when you are surrounded by the sea. If you like that, then you are in the right place at fish restaurant Messinn, a somewhat messy, cozy hut with large wooden tables and nautical paraphernalia such as model boats, lifebuoys, nets and old-fashioned sailor-tattoo drawings on the wall. Messinn is famous for its one-pot dishes with fish. Try plokkfishur, a cod and potato stew – here served with a sprig of exotic rocket for colour. This is Icelandic comfort food and according to the islanders, everyone puts their own spin on it, but the one from mother’s house is always the best – or this one from Messinn. You eat it with local rye bread, which is on the sweet side, like, er, gingerbread. You can also leave it out, it’s filling enough. Also delicious: arctic char, or migratory salmon, a salmonid that is fresher and less fatty than regular salmon.
Tip from a Dutch chef, who is very enthusiastic about the creations of Icelandic Gunnar Karl Gíslasson, a star at the stove who knows how to make something special from local organic ingredients such as the humble potato. No frills, sublime in simplicity and yet unorthodox, which ultimately results in a feast of taste. The chef finds inspiration in traditional Icelandic dishes and preparation methods (fermenting!) – Dill is a tribute to that. A beautiful establishment with a Michelin star, one for your splurge-list. Dark, robust interior with concrete, wood and mostly neutral tones. Pleasantly welcoming, especially when it's zero outside.
In the middle of the trendy harbour district of Grandi is Matur og Drykkur, a restaurant with modern Icelandic dishes that is named after an old cookbook. It goes like this: Matur og Drykkur likes to cook from those traditional cookbooks and writings, to give them a modern twist. spin moves to indicate. What that yields, you can taste in a ten-course menu – so leave those tight pants at home. The menu sways with the seasons, but you have a few certainties, namely that there is fish and lamb on the menu, seasoned with local Icelandic herbs. Pleasant place with a slightly lighter interior than many other places here: greige walls, slender Thonet chairs, floor of washed concrete. Nice long seats, good for an evening-filling program.
'Grái Kötturinn' means 'grey cat'. A fitting name, because if you've been hanging around somewhere for a long time and come back often, you're a kind of grey cat who's attached to that place, according to Icelanders. This place has that quality: a place you want to go to again and again, for the atmosphere, coffee and copious breakfast and lunch. Nonchalant American-style diner in Scandinavian style, so a bit more aesthetic than its plastic counterpart miles away, but with a cosy 1950s feel. There are also books and games, so it feels welcomingly homely here. Icelanders seem to love big portions; the Truck, American pancakes with bacon, eggs, fried potatoes, fried tomatoes, toast, syrup and butter (um, yeah, how do you come up with it, but it's a real hit here) is Huge, so you can share them very well. Also nice bagels and good coffee. Close to the center, on a corner of Hverfisgata, not so far from the harbor area.
Bakery and lunchroom during the day, but in the evening they serve the best sourdough pizzas in town. Lots of wine by the glass, nice to keep the costs under control. Early in the evening lots of families with children - because pizza, yay! - later in the evening lots of hip students and city dwellers. Housed in a cute Scandinavian wooden house, which gets its atmosphere inside through wooden poles, curved wooden Thonet chairs, low brick walls and a white painted beamed ceiling. Not fancy, pleasantly casual and always busy – so cozy.
Intimate, slightly dark place for a cocktail-à-deux and tasty bites later. Capitonated dark brown leather sofas and a mosaic of dark wooden wall panels create the atmosphere, as do the round tables with embracing circles around them and the generous chairs in burns orangeThe exciting cocktails provide an atmosphere-enhancing boost. The menu features fusion food with lots of fish and lamb and vegetarian surprises, such as the delicious mushroom ceviche – yum, really delish – and beetroot capaccio. Close to the Hallgrimskirkja, you can see it in the street, so you can grab it right away.
Monkey's may not be the best restaurant we've been to in Iceland, they lack that little bit of finesse. But a fun evening? Guaranteed. There's an old train carriage right in the middle of the place. The Champagne Train, they call it. It has to be in a carriage, we told you you're going to have fun here anyway.
The cuisine? Nikkei. A mix of Japanese and Peruvian, created when Japanese immigrants settled in Peru in the 19th century. Think: raw fish, spicy sauces, lots of flavor. A bit like OTO, but a bit less refined.
The cocktails make up for a lot. The food is also delicious, but huge portions. And they are very generous with the mayo and balsamic.
No star, but a mention in the Michelin Guide – and a well-deserved one. OTO serves imaginative Japanese-Italian fusion. Didn't think that would be a match made in heaven would be, but it is. Main stay on the menu is Japanese milk bread with different dips – try the smoked trout and roe dip and the one with tofu, sesame seeds and nori-mint oil – and then push on to different small dishes to try as much as possible, such as the delicious beetroot gyoza with ponzu and the burrata with fig, cinnamon and Thai basil. Ammaal gems, just like the cocktails here. Furthermore: nice funky place, young brigade, both young and well to do as a business audience.
Valdis Minus twenty degrees or not, Icelanders love ice cream. The best shop in town is the pastel-coloured Valdis, with two branches: a tent by the harbour and one a bit more in the centre. You know blue Smurf ice cream, that's nothing special, but definitely try the rye bread-ice cream, vanilla ice cream made with Icelandic rye bread. Don't think of those pitch-black, wet Bolletje slices that we know here as rye bread, but of a firm dark brown bread that is sweetened with lots of brown sugar, so it looks a lot like gingerbread. And then ice cream made from that. Or choose Danish licorice ice cream, also a special sensation. A scoop is already plenty of ice cream. Always busy.